Home/Blog/Retail Employee Scheduling Guide
Industry Guides

The Complete Guide to Retail Employee Scheduling in 2026

Published: March 12, 202614 min readFor Retail Managers & Store Directors

Retail scheduling is a different animal. You are not staffing a steady-state operation where the same number of people show up at the same time every day. You are staffing a business where foot traffic swings 300% between a Tuesday morning and a Saturday afternoon. Where Black Friday needs triple the crew of a normal Wednesday. Where half your team is in school, a quarter has a second job, and the rest have childcare constraints that change every semester.

The numbers tell the story. Retail has notoriously high turnover — among the highest of any major industry. Unpredictable schedules are consistently cited as a top reason retail employees leave. Understaffing drives significant lost sales across the industry. And labor typically accounts for a large share of total revenue, making it the single largest controllable expense after cost of goods.

In this environment, how you schedule is not just an HR function. It is a revenue lever. Every hour of overstaffing is money wasted. Every hour of understaffing is a customer who did not get helped, did not find what they needed, and did not come back. The schedule is the bridge between your labor budget and your sales target.

This guide is for retail managers, store directors, and district managers who build schedules for teams ranging from 10 to 200+ employees. Whether you run a single boutique or manage a chain with dozens of locations, the fundamentals are the same: match staffing to demand, stay compliant, keep your team stable, and do it all without living in a spreadsheet. Here is how.

Why Retail Scheduling Is Uniquely Difficult

Retail scheduling sits at the intersection of unpredictable demand, a highly variable workforce, and an expanding web of labor regulations. Unlike office jobs with steady 9-to-5 patterns or healthcare with consistent 24/7 coverage needs, retail demand fluctuates wildly — by hour, by day, by season, and by external events nobody can control. Here is what makes it so hard:

Extreme Demand Variability

A typical retail store sees 2-4x more foot traffic on Saturdays than Tuesdays. Holiday periods can spike 5-10x above normal. A single local event — a concert, a game, a festival — can double traffic with zero advance warning. You need dramatically different staffing levels throughout the week, and the right answer changes every week based on promotions, weather, and seasonal patterns that never repeat exactly the same way twice.

A Workforce That Does Not Sit Still

Retail has the youngest and most transient workforce of any industry. A large share of retail employees are under 25. Many are students whose availability changes every semester. Others hold second jobs with competing schedules. Turnover is notoriously high, meaning you are constantly onboarding new people while losing trained ones. The schedule has to flex around all of this while still putting experienced people on the floor during peak hours.

Multi-Department Coverage

You are not filling one role. You are staffing cashiers, floor associates, stockroom, fitting rooms, customer service, and sometimes specialized departments like electronics or cosmetics. Each has different peak patterns. Cashiers peak at checkout rushes. Floor staff peaks during browsing hours. Stockroom needs morning coverage for shipments. One schedule has to balance all of these simultaneously.

Regulatory Complexity Is Growing

Predictive scheduling laws now cover six major US cities and one entire state, with more legislation pending. These laws mandate 14-day advance schedule posting, premium pay for last-minute changes, right-to-rest provisions that ban clopening, and access-to-hours requirements that give existing staff first dibs on open shifts before you hire new people. Non-compliance penalties add up fast — $100 per violation in some jurisdictions.

The Revenue Impact

This is not abstract. When customers cannot find help on the floor, conversion rates drop. When checkout lines are too long, they abandon their carts. Stores that optimize their scheduling consistently see better sales performance and higher labor productivity. Every scheduling misstep has a direct line to your top line.

That is why retail scheduling demands more than a spreadsheet and good intentions. The variables are too many, the stakes are too high, and the margin for error is measured in revenue lost and employees who quit.

Open vs Closed Availability Systems

Before you can build a schedule, you need to know when people can work. Retail uses two fundamental approaches to availability, and choosing the right one shapes everything downstream.

Open Availability

Default: available anytime

+ Maximum scheduling flexibility for managers

+ Easier to fill hard-to-cover shifts

+ Simplifies holiday and peak period coverage

Employees feel they have no control over their lives

Drives turnover when people cannot plan around work

Often clashes with school schedules and second jobs

Common in: big-box retail, grocery chains, fast fashion

Closed Availability

Default: unavailable unless specified

+ Employees control their schedule boundaries

+ Reduces no-shows and last-minute call-outs

+ Better retention — people stay when they have predictability

Harder to fill unpopular shifts (early mornings, late nights)

Peak periods may have insufficient available staff

Requires more part-time staff to ensure coverage

Common in: specialty retail, boutiques, small chains

The Best Approach: Hybrid Availability

Most successful retailers use a hybrid model. Employees submit their recurring availability windows — the days and hours they can work each week. Managers schedule within those windows. For peak periods like holidays, the store sets broader availability requirements that all employees agree to at hire.

The key is making availability easy to update. When a student's class schedule changes mid-semester, they should be able to update their availability in 60 seconds from their phone — not fill out a paper form and wait two weeks for it to take effect. XShift lets employees set recurring weekly availability and submit one-off changes that managers can approve or adjust.

Critically, your scheduling system should flag conflicts automatically. If you schedule someone outside their stated availability, you should see a warning before you publish — not find out via a no-show on shift day.

Availability Tip

Require minimum availability thresholds at hire. For example: part-time employees must be available at least 3 days per week including one weekend day. This prevents the situation where you have 20 part-timers but none of them can work Saturday. Set expectations upfront and your schedule practically builds itself.

Managing the Part-Time / Full-Time Mix

Retail lives on its blend of full-time and part-time staff. Full-timers give you stability and experience. Part-timers give you the elasticity to scale with demand. Getting the ratio wrong in either direction costs you money and coverage.

30-40%

Optimal full-time staff ratio

60-70%

Part-time staff for flexibility

Many

Retail workers under age 25

Build Your Core With Full-Timers

Your full-time staff should be able to cover minimum staffing for every shift independently. They are your opening and closing leads, your department experts, your training backbone. Schedule them first into anchor positions — the shifts and roles that absolutely must be covered by someone experienced. Then layer part-time hours on top to match demand curves.

Schedule Students Around Class Times

Student employees are your evenings and weekends workforce. Their availability shifts every semester — January, May, and August are your adjustment periods. Build a system that collects updated class schedules proactively. Do not wait for them to tell you after the schedule is published. XShift's recurring availability feature lets students set semester-based patterns that automatically update when they submit changes, eliminating the back-and-forth of paper availability forms.

Respect Second Jobs

Many retail workers hold more than one job. If you schedule them in conflict with their other employer, they will not call in sick — they will quit whichever job is less flexible. Collect second-job commitments as part of availability and treat them as hard constraints, not suggestions. A reliable part-timer who works 15 hours a week around a fixed second-job schedule is worth more than a full-availability hire who quits in two months.

Seasonal Hiring Strategy

For holiday seasons, start onboarding seasonal hires 6-8 weeks before peak. Schedule them alongside experienced staff for the first two weeks so they learn the floor and the systems. Gradually increase their independent shifts as they ramp up. After the season, offer your best seasonal hires permanent part-time positions — they are already trained and they already know your operation. This converts your seasonal investment into long-term workforce stability.

Predictive Scheduling Laws and Compliance

The regulatory landscape for retail scheduling has shifted dramatically over the past decade. What started with early ordinances in San Francisco has expanded into a patchwork of laws across major US cities and one entire state. If you operate retail locations in any of these jurisdictions, compliance is not optional — and the penalties for violations are significant.

Where Predictive Scheduling Laws Apply (2026)

JurisdictionAdvance NoticeRest PeriodApplies To
Oregon (statewide)14 days10 hoursRetail/food, 500+ employees
New York City14 days11 hoursFast food, 30+ locations
Chicago14 days10 hoursRetail/hospitality, 100+ employees
Seattle14 days10 hoursRetail/food, 500+ worldwide
San Francisco14 daysNo mandateRetail chain, 40+ locations
Los Angeles14 days10 hoursRetail, 300+ employees

Advance Notice Requirements

Most current predictive scheduling laws require 14 days advance notice before the schedule takes effect. Changes made after posting trigger "predictability pay" — the exact amount varies by jurisdiction, but penalties increase the closer the change is to the shift. In practice, this means your schedule needs to be finalized and published two full weeks before the start of the schedule period. No more last-minute schedules posted on Friday for a Monday start. Check your specific jurisdiction for exact predictability pay calculations.

Clopening and Right-to-Rest

Clopening — scheduling an employee to close the store and then open it the next morning — is now restricted or banned in most predictive scheduling jurisdictions. Several cities and states require minimum rest periods of 10-11 hours between shifts. If an employee agrees to work a clopening shift voluntarily, some jurisdictions require a premium for the hours that fall within the rest period. The specific rules and premiums vary by location — check your jurisdiction's requirements and build rest period awareness into your scheduling process.

Access-to-Hours Provisions

Several jurisdictions require that existing employees be offered additional hours before new hires are brought on. This means open shifts must be posted internally first, with a reasonable acceptance window, before you can hire new part-timers to fill gaps. XShift's shift drop and pickup feature lets employees post shifts they cannot work and allows other qualified employees to pick them up — giving existing staff first access to available hours.

Compliance Is Coming Everywhere

Even if you do not currently operate in a predictive scheduling jurisdiction, the trend is clear: more cities and states are adopting these laws every year. Building your scheduling process around 14-day advance notice and minimum rest periods now means you will not have to scramble when new legislation hits your area. Treat these not as burdens but as best practices that reduce turnover and improve employee satisfaction regardless of legal requirements.

Peak Hour Coverage and SPLH Optimization

The single most important metric in retail scheduling is sales per labor hour (SPLH). It tells you whether your labor investment is generating proportional revenue — or whether you are paying people to stand around during slow periods and leaving money on the table during busy ones.

How to Calculate and Use SPLH

Formula

SPLH = Total Sales / Total Labor Hours

$150-250

Specialty retail SPLH

$100-150

Grocery SPLH

$175-300

Big-box retail SPLH

Track SPLH by hour of day and day of week. You will quickly see patterns: Saturday 11 AM-3 PM might run $300 SPLH (meaning you need more staff), while Tuesday 2-5 PM might show $80 SPLH (meaning you could trim an associate). The goal is not to maximize SPLH everywhere — that would mean permanently understaffing. The goal is to flatten the curve: add hours where SPLH is too high (customers not getting served) and trim where it is too low (paying for idle time).

Map Your Traffic Curves

Use POS data, door counters, or transaction timestamps to build hourly traffic profiles for each day of the week. Most retail stores follow a predictable intraday pattern: slow open, building through late morning, peak around lunch or mid-afternoon, a dip, then a secondary peak in the early evening. Your schedule should mirror this curve. If you have 8 people on the floor at 10 AM and 8 people at 3 PM but your traffic is 3x higher at 3 PM, your schedule is wrong — even though total hours might be right.

Stagger Start Times

Do not start everyone at the same time. If your store opens at 10 AM and all 12 associates clock in at 9:45, you have maximum staff during the slowest hour and start losing people just as traffic peaks. Instead, bring in your opening crew at 9:45 for setup, stagger additional associates at 11, 12, and 1 PM to match the traffic ramp, and schedule evening associates to overlap with the late-afternoon peak before the day crew leaves.

Use Labor Budgets, Not Headcount Targets

Stop thinking in "I need 6 people today" and start thinking in "I have 52 labor hours to deploy today." A labor-hours approach lets you flex: maybe Tuesday needs 40 hours spread thin over 12 hours of operation, while Saturday needs 80 hours concentrated into 8 peak hours. Set weekly labor budgets as a percentage of projected sales — typically 12-18% for retail — and distribute hours to match where the revenue actually is.

Holiday Staffing Formula

For Black Friday and holiday peaks, calculate labor needs from prior-year sales data: take last year's hourly sales for the same day, divide by your target SPLH, and you have the labor hours needed per hour. Add 10-15% buffer for customer service quality during high-stress periods. This data-driven approach prevents both the understaffing that kills sales and the overstaffing that kills margins.

Cross-Training and Department Coverage

In retail, an employee who can only work one department is a scheduling constraint. An employee who can work three departments is scheduling freedom. Cross-training is not a nice-to-have — it is the single most effective way to increase scheduling flexibility without increasing headcount.

How to set this up in XShift

Go to your organization's advanced settings and turn on multi-role assignments. Then assign each employee a primary role (their main department) and one or more secondary roles (departments they're cross-trained in). When the AI generates schedules, it favors placing employees in their primary role first, then fills remaining coverage gaps with secondary-role-qualified staff. Your cashier who's cross-trained on the floor only gets pulled to the sales floor when there's an actual need — not by default.

Cashier / Register

Peak demand follows transaction volume, which spikes at lunch, after work, and weekends. Every floor associate should have basic register training so they can jump on during checkout rushes. This alone can significantly reduce customer wait times during peaks without adding any labor hours.

Cross-train from: floor associates, customer service

Sales Floor

Floor coverage drives conversion rates. Customers who interact with an associate are far more likely to purchase. Schedule floor associates to match browsing hours, not just open-to-close. Afternoons and weekends need the most floor coverage; early mornings need the least.

Cross-train from: stockroom, fitting room, cashier

Stockroom / Receiving

Stockroom peaks follow delivery schedules — typically early mornings on set days. Schedule your heaviest stockroom coverage for receiving windows, then redeploy those associates to the floor once product is processed. A stockroom associate who can also work the floor gives you 2-3 extra selling hours per shift.

Cross-train to: floor, cashier during peak hours

Fitting Room / Customer Service

These are often the most understaffed areas because they do not directly ring sales. But fitting room abandonment directly impacts conversion — customers who cannot get help in the fitting room often leave without purchasing. Schedule dedicated coverage during peak try-on hours (typically 12-6 PM weekdays, 11 AM-5 PM weekends).

Cross-train from: floor associates, cashier

Building a Cross-Training Matrix

Create a skills matrix that maps every employee to every department they are trained for. Start with a goal of training every employee in at least two departments. Your most versatile associates — trained in three or four areas — become your schedule anchors. They can fill gaps anywhere, which means fewer holes and fewer last-minute scrambles.

XShift's role-based scheduling makes this concrete. Set up roles for each department (Cashier, Floor, Stockroom, Fitting Room, Customer Service). Assign employees to every role they are qualified for. When the AI generates schedules, it matches people to roles based on coverage needs and their assigned roles — automatically deploying your most versatile staff where they are needed most.

The 2-Department Minimum Rule

Make cross-training a condition of advancement. Associates trained in two or more departments should be prioritized for raises and promotions. This creates a natural incentive for employees to expand their skills while simultaneously building the scheduling flexibility you need. Within a few months, most stores find the majority of staff trained in at least two areas.

Split Shifts, Swaps, and Schedule Changes

A published schedule is a starting point, not a contract. People get sick. Cars break down. Childcare falls through. How you handle changes after publication determines whether your operation runs smoothly or descends into chaos.

Split Shifts: When They Work and When They Do Not

A split shift breaks the workday into two segments with an unpaid gap in between — for example, 10 AM to 1 PM, then 4 PM to 8 PM. In theory, this lets you staff both the lunch rush and the after-work peak without paying for the slow 1-4 PM window. In practice, split shifts are deeply unpopular with employees because they consume an entire day for part-time pay.

California and several other states require split-shift premiums — an extra hour of pay at minimum wage for any day that includes a split. Even where not legally required, overuse of split shifts drives turnover. Use them sparingly and only when the demand pattern genuinely requires it. For most retail operations, staggered straight shifts achieve the same coverage without the morale hit.

Best practice: Reserve split shifts for volunteers or employees who specifically prefer them (some parents prefer a morning shift, school pickup, then evening shift). Never assign them as punishment or default.

Shift Swaps: Make Them Self-Service

The number one source of schedule disruption is employees who cannot work their assigned shift and have no easy way to find coverage. The traditional process — call the manager, manager calls around to find a replacement, texts back and forth, finally confirms — takes 30-60 minutes per swap and usually falls on the manager's time off.

Self-service shift trading through a platform like XShift eliminates this bottleneck. An employee posts their shift as available for swap. Qualified coworkers see it and claim it. The system verifies there are no overtime conflicts, no rest-period violations, and no department coverage gaps. The swap completes in minutes with zero manager intervention. Managers get notified but do not have to broker the deal. This single feature typically saves retail managers 3-5 hours per week in schedule management overhead.

Handling Call-Outs and No-Shows

Retail typically sees a few unplanned absences per week. For a 30-person team, that means you should expect 1-2 unplanned absences on any given day. Build your schedule expecting this: slightly overstaffing critical periods so that a single call-out does not crater your floor coverage.

When a call-out happens, send the open shift to all qualified, available employees immediately via push notification. The first person to claim it gets it. This replaces the manager-as-switchboard model where one person spends 45 minutes calling down a list. Speed matters — a shift filled within 30 minutes of a call-out has no customer impact. A shift filled 4 hours in, or not at all, costs you sales.

Schedule Change Documentation

In predictive scheduling jurisdictions, every change after the schedule is posted must be documented with the affected employee's written consent and the associated premium pay recorded. Paper systems crumble under this requirement. Digital scheduling platforms make it easier to track changes and maintain records. Read our complete guide to shift swaps for more on managing changes after publication.

How AI Scheduling Transforms Retail Operations

Manual scheduling in retail means a manager sitting with a spreadsheet, trying to remember that last Saturday was busy because of a sale, next Saturday might be slow because of a holiday weekend, and three of their best cashiers have midterms. AI scheduling does not replace managerial judgment. It handles the computational complexity — matching dozens of employees to shifts while respecting availability, roles, overtime limits, and fairness constraints — so managers can focus on the human decisions that actually require experience.

AI Schedule Generation

Tell XShift's AI copilot what you need — how many people per role, which days to cover, any special requirements — and it generates a complete schedule in seconds. You can also create shifts, assign employees, and adjust schedules through a conversational chat interface. FAIR mode distributes hours evenly; MAX mode prioritizes your top performers for peak coverage.

AI Schedule Generation

Generate a complete weekly schedule in seconds. FAIR mode distributes shifts evenly across all eligible staff — hours, weekends, and holidays included. MAX mode prioritizes peak coverage by scheduling your strongest team during the highest-traffic hours. Both modes respect individual availability, employee preferences, overtime, role requirements, and PTO automatically.

Shift Trading and Open Shifts

Employees swap shifts through the app with automatic validation of department qualifications, overtime limits, and rest periods. Open shifts from call-outs push to all eligible employees instantly. The first qualified person to claim it gets it. No more manager phone trees. Coverage stays intact and compliance stays clean.

Role-Based Department Scheduling

Set up roles for every department: Cashier, Floor, Stockroom, Fitting Room, Customer Service. Assign employees to the roles they are trained for. The AI schedules people into roles they are qualified for, ensuring every department has the right coverage at the right time. Cross-trained employees automatically fill wherever need is greatest.

In-App Messaging and Group Chats

XShift includes built-in messaging so managers and employees can communicate directly within the platform. Send messages to individual employees or create group chats for teams, departments, or locations. No more texting personal phones or chasing people down on the floor — schedule-related communication lives in the same place as the schedule itself.

Labor Cost Optimization

Track labor costs with built-in analytics that show overtime hours, scheduled vs actual hours, and labor spend across your team. XShift tracks each employee's weekly hours against the 40-hour overtime threshold so you can see who is approaching the limit and redistribute shifts before hitting 1.5x pay rates. Reports cover hours worked, coverage patterns, and overtime trends — giving you the data to make smarter staffing decisions week over week.

The Time Savings Are Real

The average retail manager spends 6-8 hours per week building and managing schedules. That is 300-400 hours per year — nearly two full months of work — spent on a task that software can do in minutes. Those hours are not free. They come directly from time that could be spent on the floor coaching associates, managing inventory, improving visual merchandising, and doing the work that actually drives sales.

AI scheduling does not just save manager time. It produces better schedules. A human building a schedule for 30 employees across 5 departments with varying availability, compliance constraints, and demand curves is solving an optimization problem with thousands of variables. They will find a workable answer. The AI will find a better one — one that matches staffing to demand more precisely, distributes hours more fairly, and catches compliance issues that a tired manager working on their day off would miss.

Multi-Location Scheduling

For retail chains, XShift manages each location independently with its own staffing rules, templates, and department structure — while giving head managers visibility across all locations. Managers can be assigned permissions by location and by action, so a store manager only sees and edits their own location while a district manager has access across multiple stores. Control who can publish schedules, approve shift swaps, manage PTO, or edit employee profiles — all configurable per manager. One platform, full visibility, no blind spots. Learn more about how AI replaces manual scheduling processes across multi-location operations.

Stop Guessing.
Start Scheduling Smarter.

Every hour your store manager spends wrestling with a spreadsheet is an hour they are not on the floor driving sales. Every understaffed peak hour is revenue walking out the door. Every burned-out associate who quits costs thousands in replacement and training.

The schedule is not supposed to be the hardest part of running a store. It is supposed to be the foundation that puts the right people in the right departments at the right times — every day, automatically.

XShift handles retail scheduling with AI-powered schedule generation in FAIR or MAX mode, role-based department assignments, self-service shift trading, multi-location management, overtime tracking, and labor cost analytics — all generated in seconds through a conversational AI copilot, not hours of spreadsheet work.

30-day free trial.

?

Retail Employee Scheduling FAQ

What are predictive scheduling laws and which cities enforce them?

Predictive scheduling laws require employers to provide advance notice of schedules (typically 14 days) and pay penalties for last-minute changes. As of 2026, Oregon enforces statewide predictive scheduling for retail and food service employers with 500+ employees. Cities with their own ordinances include New York City, Chicago, Seattle, San Francisco, Los Angeles, and Philadelphia. Penalties range from 1 to 4 hours of additional pay per affected shift depending on the jurisdiction and how late the change was made.

How do you schedule retail employees around Black Friday and holiday peaks?

Start planning holiday schedules 6-8 weeks in advance. Collect availability early and set clear expectations that holiday periods require broader availability. Use prior-year sales data to forecast staffing needs by department and hour. Cross-train employees for multi-department coverage during surges. Offer premium pay or first-pick incentives for holiday shifts. Build your schedule in layers: skeleton crew of reliable full-timers first, then part-timers and seasonal hires for additional capacity. AI scheduling tools can generate optimized holiday schedules in seconds, respecting availability, role requirements, and overtime limits automatically.

What is the ideal ratio of full-time to part-time retail employees?

Most retail operations run best with 30-40% full-time and 60-70% part-time staff. Full-timers provide schedule stability, institutional knowledge, and opening/closing leadership. Part-timers give you the flexibility to scale with demand. The exact ratio depends on your traffic patterns: stores with extreme weekend peaks need more part-timers, while stores with steady weekday traffic can rely more on full-time staff. Ensure your full-time core can cover minimum staffing independently, with part-timers adding capacity during peaks.

How do you calculate sales per labor hour (SPLH) for retail scheduling?

SPLH equals total sales divided by total labor hours worked. Track it by day of week, hour, and department to identify overstaffing and understaffing. Industry benchmarks vary: specialty retail averages $150-250, grocery runs $100-150, and big-box stores target $175-300. Use SPLH trends to adjust scheduling — add hours where SPLH is consistently too high (customers not getting served) and trim where it is too low (idle labor). The goal is not maximum SPLH but consistent SPLH across all operating hours.

What is clopening and why is it a problem in retail?

Clopening is when an employee closes the store at night and opens it the next morning, leaving fewer than 10-11 hours between shifts. After commuting, a closer-opener might get only 5-6 hours of sleep. This causes fatigue, increases errors, damages morale, and drives turnover. Multiple jurisdictions now ban or restrict clopening. Oregon requires 10 hours between shifts, Seattle and NYC require 11. Violations trigger premium pay penalties. Your scheduling software should automatically prevent clopening by enforcing minimum rest periods.

How can AI help with retail employee scheduling?

AI scheduling generates optimized schedules that match your staffing requirements to available employees while respecting availability, role qualifications, overtime limits, and fairness constraints. XShift's AI copilot lets you generate complete schedules through a chat interface — just describe what you need and it builds the schedule in seconds. FAIR mode distributes shifts equitably across all staff, while MAX mode prioritizes your strongest performers for peak hours. The result: better coverage, fairer distribution, and 6-8 hours saved per week on manual schedule building.

The Bottom Line

Retail scheduling is not an administrative task. It is a revenue function. Every understaffed peak hour costs you sales. Every overstaffed slow period wastes labor dollars. Every unpredictable schedule that drives an experienced associate to quit costs you thousands in turnover and months of training investment.

The retailers who win in 2026 are the ones who treat scheduling as a strategic capability, not a chore. They use data to match staffing to demand. They cross-train to maximize flexibility. They schedule effectively to match demand. They give employees predictability and control. And they use AI to handle the optimization that no human can do with a spreadsheet.

Your employees did not sign up to fight over schedules. Your managers did not sign up to spend their weekends building them. Build a system that works for both — and watch what happens to your sales, your retention, and your bottom line.

Related Guides

Retail Employee Scheduling Guide for Managers